The Myth of Judicial Independence
Title | The Myth of Judicial Independence PDF eBook |
Author | Mike McConville |
Publisher | Oxford University Press |
Total Pages | 288 |
Release | 2020-06-28 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0192555278 |
Through an examination of the history of the rules that regulate police interrogation (the Judges' Rules) in conjunction with plea bargaining and the Criminal Procedure Rules, this book explores the 'Westminster Model' under which three arms of the State (parliament, the executive, and the judiciary) operate independently of one another. It reveals how policy was framed in secret meetings with the executive which then actively misled parliament in contradiction to its ostensible formal relationship with the legislature. This analysis of Home Office archives shows how the worldwide significance of the Judges' Rules was secured not simply by the standing of the English judiciary and the political power of the empire but more significantly by the false representation that the Rules were the handiwork of judges rather than civil servants and politicians. The book critically examines the claim repeatedly advanced by judges that "judicial independence" is justified by principles arising from the "rule of law" and instead shows that the "rule of law" depends upon basic principles of the common law, including an adversarial process and trial by jury, and that the underpinnings of judicial action in criminal justice today may be ideological rather than based on principles.
The Myth of Judicial Independence
Title | The Myth of Judicial Independence PDF eBook |
Author | Mike McConville |
Publisher | Oxford University Press, USA |
Total Pages | 337 |
Release | 2020-06-29 |
Genre | |
ISBN | 0198822103 |
Through an examination of the history of the rules that regulate police interrogation (the Judges' Rules) in conjunction with plea bargaining and the Criminal Procedure Rules, this book explores the 'Westminster Model' under which three arms of the State (parliament, the executive, and the judiciary) operate independently of one another. It reveals how policy was framed in secret meetings with the executive which then actively misled parliament in contradiction to its ostensible formal relationship with the legislature. This analysis of Home Office archives shows how the worldwide significance of the Judges' Rules was secured not simply by the standing of the English judiciary and the political power of the empire but more significantly by the false representation that the Rules were the handiwork of judges rather than civil servants and politicians. The book critically examines the claim repeatedly advanced by judges that "judicial independence" is justified by principles arising from the "rule of law" and instead shows that the "rule of law" depends upon basic principles of the common law, including an adversarial process and trial by jury, and that the underpinnings of judicial action in criminal justice today may be ideological rather than based on principles.
Judicial Independence
Title | Judicial Independence PDF eBook |
Author | P. B. Sawant |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 66 |
Release | 2003 |
Genre | Judicial power |
ISBN |
The Culture of Judicial Independence
Title | The Culture of Judicial Independence PDF eBook |
Author | Shimon Shetreet |
Publisher | Martinus Nijhoff Publishers |
Total Pages | 689 |
Release | 2011-11-11 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 9004215859 |
The creation of a culture of Judicial Independence is of a central significance both in national domestic legal systems, as well as for the international courts and tribunals. The main aim of this volume is to analyze the development of a culture of Judicial Independence in comparative perspectives, to offer an examination of the conceptual foundations of the principle of judicial independence and to discuss in detail the practical challenges facing judiciaries in different jurisdictions. The proposed volume is based on the papers presented at the five conferences held in the framework of The International Project on Judicial independence. The editors of this volume and the contributors to it are leading scholars and distinguished experts on judicial independence and judiciaries.
Judicial Independence: Myth and Reality
Title | Judicial Independence: Myth and Reality PDF eBook |
Author | P. B. Sawant |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 71 |
Release | 1988 |
Genre | |
ISBN |
The Myth of the Imperial Judiciary
Title | The Myth of the Imperial Judiciary PDF eBook |
Author | Mark Kozlowski |
Publisher | NYU Press |
Total Pages | 309 |
Release | 2006-01-01 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0814749291 |
Few institutions have become as ferociously fought over in democratic politics as the courts. While political criticism of judges in this country goes back to its inception, today’s intensely ideological assault is nearly unprecedented. Spend any amount of time among the writings of contemporary right-wing critics of judicial power, and you are virtually assured of seeing repeated complaints about the “imperial judiciary.” American conservatives contend not only that judicial power has expanded dangerously in recent decades, but that liberal judges now willfully write their policy preferences into law. They raise alarms that American courts possess a degree of power incompatible with the functioning of a democratic polity. The Myth of the Imperial Judiciary explores the anti-judicial ideological trend of the American right, refuting these claims and taking a realistic look at the role of courts in our democracy to show that conservatives have a highly unrealistic conception of their power. Kozlowski first assesses the validity of the conservative view of the Founders’ intent, arguing that courts have played an assertive role in our politics since their establishment. He then considers contemporary judicial powers to show that conservatives have greatly overstated the extent to which the expansion of rights which has occurred has worked solely to the benefit of liberals. Kozlowski reveals the ways in which the claims of those on the right are often either unsupported or simply wrong. He concludes that American courts, far from imperiling our democracy or our moral fabric, stand as a bulwark against the abuse of legislative power, acting forcefully, as they have always done, to give meaning to constitutional promises.
The Myth of Judicial Independence in Nigeria
Title | The Myth of Judicial Independence in Nigeria PDF eBook |
Author | Opeyemi Akanbi |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 154 |
Release | 2012 |
Genre | |
ISBN |