The Intricacies of Dicta and Dissent
Title | The Intricacies of Dicta and Dissent PDF eBook |
Author | Neil Duxbury |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 513 |
Release | 2021-08-12 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1108898815 |
Common-law judgments tend to be more than merely judgments, for judges often make pronouncements that they need not have made had they kept strictly to the task in hand. Why do they do this? The Intricacies of Dicta and Dissent examines two such types of pronouncement, obiter dicta and dissenting opinions, primarily as aspects of English case law. Neil Duxbury shows that both of these phenomena have complex histories, have been put to a variety of uses, and are not amenable to being straightforwardly categorized as secondary sources of law. This innovative and unusual study casts new light on – and will prompt lawyers to pose fresh questions about – the common law tradition and the nature of judicial decision-making.
The Nature and Authority of Precedent
Title | The Nature and Authority of Precedent PDF eBook |
Author | Neil Duxbury |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 189 |
Release | 2008 |
Genre | Judicial process |
ISBN | 9781107186583 |
Neil Duxbury examines how precedents constrain legal decision-makers and how legal decision-makers relax and avoid those constraints. There is no single principle or theory which explains the authority of precedent but rather a number of arguments which raise rebuttable presumptions in favour of precedent-following. This book examines the force and the limitations of these arguments and shows that although the principal requirement of the doctrine of precedent is that courts respect earlier judicial decisions on materially identical facts, the doctrine also requires courts to depart from such decisions when following them would perpetuate legal error or injustice. Not only do judicial precedents not 'bind' judges in the classical-positivist sense, but, were they to do so, they would be ill suited to common-law decision-making. Combining historical inquiry and philosophical analysis, this book will assist anyone seeking to understand how precedent operates as a common-law doctrine.
Elements of Legislation
Title | Elements of Legislation PDF eBook |
Author | Neil Duxbury |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 267 |
Release | 2013 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1107021871 |
Neil Duxbury combines analytical legal philosophy and legal history to explore the concept of legislation.
Dissenting Voices in American Society
Title | Dissenting Voices in American Society PDF eBook |
Author | Austin Sarat |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 251 |
Release | 2012-01-31 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1107378990 |
Dissenting Voices in American Society: The Role of Judges, Lawyers, and Citizens explores the status of dissent in the work and lives of judges, lawyers, and citizens, and in our institutions and culture. It brings together under the lens of critical examination dissenting voices that are usually treated separately: the protester, the academic critic, the intellectual, and the dissenting judge. It examines the forms of dissent that institutions make possible and those that are discouraged or domesticated. This book also describes the kinds of stories that dissenting voices try to tell and the narrative tropes on which those stories depend. This book is the product of an integrated series of symposia at the University of Alabama School of Law. These symposia bring leading scholars into colloquy with faculty at the law school on subjects at the cutting edge of interdisciplinary inquiry in law.
Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers
Title | Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers PDF eBook |
Author | M. J. C. Vile |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 0 |
Release | 1998 |
Genre | History |
ISBN | 9780865971752 |
Vile traces the history of the doctrine from its rise during the English Civil War, through its development in the eighteenth century -- through subsequent political thought and constitution-making in Britain, France, and the United States.
Philosophical Foundations of Precedent
Title | Philosophical Foundations of Precedent PDF eBook |
Author | Timothy Endicott |
Publisher | Oxford University Press |
Total Pages | 577 |
Release | 2023-02-13 |
Genre | Stare decisis |
ISBN | 019285724X |
Philosophical Foundations of Precedent offers a broad, deep, and diverse range of philosophical investigations of the role of precedent in law, adjudication, and morality. The forty chapters present the work of a large and inclusive group of authors which comprises of well-established leaders in the discipline and new voices in legal philosophy. The magnitude of the resulting project is extraordinary, presenting a diverse array of innovative and creative philosophical investigations of the practice of adhering to past decisions, in law and allied fields of practical reasoning. And by the same token, the contributions elucidate the reasons that courts and other decision-makers may have for departing from what has been done before. The phenomena under investigation include the law and practice of common law and civil jurisdictions around the world. In addition to its fundamental relevance to common law jurisdictions, this work will be of broad and significant interest to theoretically minded audiences in continental Europe, Latin America, and Asia because it involves an extensive study of practices of precedent in civil law systems as well as common law systems.
Comparative Constitutional Reasoning
Title | Comparative Constitutional Reasoning PDF eBook |
Author | András Jakab |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 867 |
Release | 2017-04-27 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1108138616 |
To what extent is the language of judicial opinions responsive to the political and social context in which constitutional courts operate? Courts are reason-giving institutions, with argumentation playing a central role in constitutional adjudication. However, a cursory look at just a handful of constitutional systems suggests important differences in the practices of constitutional judges, whether in matters of form, style, or language. Focusing on independently-verified leading cases globally, a combination of qualitative and quantitative analysis offers the most comprehensive and systematic account of constitutional reasoning to date. This analysis is supported by the examination of eighteen legal systems around the world including the European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice. Universally common aspects of constitutional reasoning are identified in this book, and contributors also examine whether common law countries differ to civil law countries in this respect.