Negotiating the Constitution
Title | Negotiating the Constitution PDF eBook |
Author | Joseph M. Lynch |
Publisher | Cornell University Press |
Total Pages | 340 |
Release | 2005 |
Genre | History |
ISBN | 9780801472718 |
No concept sparks more controversy in constitutional debate than "original intent." Offering a legal historian's approach to the subject, this book demonstrates that the framers deliberately obscured one of their more important decisions. Joseph M. Lynch argues that the Constitution was a product of political struggles involving regional interests, economic concerns, and ideology. The framers, he maintains, settled on enigmatic wording of the Necessary and Proper Clause and of the General Welfare provision in the Spending Clause as a compromise, leaving the extent of federal power to be determined by the political process. During ratification, however, attempts by dissident framers to undo the compromise were repelled in The Federalist: charges of overly broad congressional powers were met with protestations that in fact these powers were limited. Lynch describes how early lawmakers applied the Constitution to such issues as executive power and privilege, the deportation of aliens, and the prohibition of seditious speech. He follows the disputes over the interpretation of this document--focusing on James Madison's changing views--as the new government took shape and political parties were formed. Lynch points out that the first six Congresses and President George Washington disregarded the framers' intentions when they were deemed impractical to follow. In contrast, he warns that the version of original intent put forth in recent Supreme Court opinions regarding congressional power could hinder Congress in serving the nation.
The Negotiable Constitution
Title | The Negotiable Constitution PDF eBook |
Author | Grégoire C. N. Webber |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 241 |
Release | 2009-11-26 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1139483730 |
In matters of rights, constitutions tend to avoid settling controversies. With few exceptions, rights are formulated in open-ended language, seeking consensus on an abstraction without purporting to resolve the many moral-political questions implicated by rights. The resulting view has been that rights extend everywhere but are everywhere infringed by legislation seeking to resolve the very moral-political questions the constitution seeks to avoid. The Negotiable Constitution challenges this view. Arguing that underspecified rights call for greater specification, Grégoire C. N. Webber draws on limitation clauses common to most bills of rights to develop a new understanding of the relationship between rights and legislation. The legislature is situated as a key constitutional actor tasked with completing the specification of constitutional rights. In turn, because the constitutional project is incomplete with regards to rights, it is open to being re-negotiated by legislation struggling with the very moral-political questions left underdetermined at the constitutional level.
Constitutional Negotiations
Title | Constitutional Negotiations PDF eBook |
Author | Sumit Bisarya and Thibaut Noel |
Publisher | International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA) |
Total Pages | 14 |
Release | 2021-04-26 |
Genre | Political Science |
ISBN | 9176714144 |
Countries often amend their constitutions or enact new ones following major political events, such as the founding of newly independent states, the fall of an authoritarian regime or the end of violent conflict. Significant constitutional reform at a crucial moment is often a high-stakes process because a constitution regulates access to public power and resources among different groups. While disagreements over divisive topics are likely and even inherent to constitution-making, they may also result in a serious deadlock when stakeholders are unable to reach agreement. A prolonged deadlock can delay or even derail the whole reform process. In this context, it may be advisable to create incentives that can help parties to the negotiations overcome divergence and resolve deadlocks should they occur. This Constitution Brief focuses on strategies and mechanisms for breaking a deadlock in constitutional negotiations conducted in an environment of competitive democratic politics.
Negotiating in Civil Conflict
Title | Negotiating in Civil Conflict PDF eBook |
Author | Haider Ala Hamoudi |
Publisher | University of Chicago Press |
Total Pages | 326 |
Release | 2013-11-12 |
Genre | Political Science |
ISBN | 022606879X |
In 2005, Iraq drafted its first constitution and held the country’s first democratic election in more than fifty years. Even under ideal conditions, drafting a constitution can be a prolonged process marked by contentious debate, and conditions in Iraq are far from ideal: Iraq has long been racked by ethnic and sectarian conflict, which intensified following the American invasion and continues today. This severe division, which often erupted into violence, would not seem to bode well for the fate of democracy. So how is it that Iraq was able to surmount its sectarianism to draft a constitution that speaks to the conflicting and largely incompatible ideological view of the Sunnis, Shi’ah, and Kurds? Haider Ala Hamoudi served in 2009 as an adviser to Iraq’s Constitutional Review Committee, and he argues here that the terms of the Iraqi Constitution are sufficiently capacious to be interpreted in a variety of ways, allowing it to appeal to the country’s three main sects despite their deep disagreements. While some say that this ambiguity avoids the challenging compromises that ultimately must be made if the state is to survive, Hamoudi maintains that to force these compromises on issues of central importance to ethnic and sectarian identity would almost certainly result in the imposition of one group’s views on the others. Drawing on the original negotiating documents, he shows that this feature of the Constitution was not an act of evasion, as is sometimes thought, but a mark of its drafters’ awareness in recognizing the need to permit the groups the time necessary to develop their own methods of working with one another over time.
Negotiating the Ottoman Constitution 1839-1876
Title | Negotiating the Ottoman Constitution 1839-1876 PDF eBook |
Author | Aylin Kocunyan |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 491 |
Release | 2018 |
Genre | |
ISBN | 9782758402824 |
Negotiating Justice
Title | Negotiating Justice PDF eBook |
Author | Mervyn Bennun |
Publisher | |
Total Pages | 216 |
Release | 1995 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN |
The book is concerned with the transfer of power in South Africa. It illustrates the issues that the ordinary South African and those entrusted with the task of building the new state were forced to consider, such as human rights, land reform, the future of the Homelands and the validity of the democratic process. The book focuses on these issues in a period that saw the spread of communal violence on such a horrific scale that many prophesied the outbreak of civil war.
Czecho/Slovakia
Title | Czecho/Slovakia PDF eBook |
Author | Eric Stein |
Publisher | University of Michigan Press |
Total Pages | 420 |
Release | 2000-01-26 |
Genre | History |
ISBN | 9780472086283 |
DIVDescribes the peaceful breakup of the Czechoslovak Federation /div