Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court
Title | Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court PDF eBook |
Author | Richard H. Fallon |
Publisher | Harvard University Press |
Total Pages | 237 |
Release | 2018-02-19 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0674975812 |
Legitimacy and judicial authority -- Constitutional meaning : original public meaning -- Constitutional meaning : varieties of history that matter -- Law in the Supreme Court : jurisprudential foundations -- Constitutional constraints -- Constitutional theory and its relation to constitutional practice -- Sociological, legal, and moral legitimacy : today and tomorrow
Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court
Title | Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court PDF eBook |
Author | Richard H. Fallon Jr. |
Publisher | Harvard University Press |
Total Pages | 240 |
Release | 2018-02-19 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0674986091 |
Why do self-proclaimed constitutional “originalists” so regularly reach decisions with a politically conservative valence? Do “living constitutionalists” claim a license to reach whatever results they prefer, without regard to the Constitution’s language and history? In confronting these questions, Richard H. Fallon reframes and ultimately transcends familiar debates about constitutional law, constitutional theory, and judicial legitimacy. Drawing from ideas in legal scholarship, philosophy, and political science, Fallon presents a theory of judicial legitimacy based on an ideal of good faith in constitutional argumentation. Good faith demands that the Justices base their decisions only on legal arguments that they genuinely believe to be valid and are prepared to apply to similar future cases. Originalists are correct about this much. But good faith does not forbid the Justices to refine and adjust their interpretive theories in response to the novel challenges that new cases present. Fallon argues that theories of constitutional interpretation should be works in progress, not rigid formulas laid down in advance of the unforeseeable challenges that life and experience generate. Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court offers theories of constitutional law and judicial legitimacy that accept many tenets of legal realism but reject its corrosive cynicism. Fallon’s account both illuminates current practice and prescribes urgently needed responses to a legitimacy crisis in which the Supreme Court is increasingly enmeshed.
The Authority of the Court and the Peril of Politics
Title | The Authority of the Court and the Peril of Politics PDF eBook |
Author | Stephen Breyer |
Publisher | Harvard University Press |
Total Pages | 113 |
Release | 2021-09-14 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0674269365 |
A sitting justice reflects upon the authority of the Supreme CourtÑhow that authority was gained and how measures to restructure the Court could undermine both the Court and the constitutional system of checks and balances that depends on it. A growing chorus of officials and commentators argues that the Supreme Court has become too political. On this view the confirmation process is just an exercise in partisan agenda-setting, and the jurists are no more than Òpoliticians in robesÓÑtheir ostensibly neutral judicial philosophies mere camouflage for conservative or liberal convictions. Stephen Breyer, drawing upon his experience as a Supreme Court justice, sounds a cautionary note. Mindful of the CourtÕs history, he suggests that the judiciaryÕs hard-won authority could be marred by reforms premised on the assumption of ideological bias. Having, as Hamilton observed, Òno influence over either the sword or the purse,Ó the Court earned its authority by making decisions that have, over time, increased the publicÕs trust. If public trust is now in decline, one part of the solution is to promote better understandings of how the judiciary actually works: how judges adhere to their oaths and how they try to avoid considerations of politics and popularity. Breyer warns that political intervention could itself further erode public trust. Without the publicÕs trust, the Court would no longer be able to act as a check on the other branches of government or as a guarantor of the rule of law, risking serious harm to our constitutional system.
Extra-Legal Power and Legitimacy
Title | Extra-Legal Power and Legitimacy PDF eBook |
Author | Clement Fatovic |
Publisher | Oxford University Press |
Total Pages | 253 |
Release | 2013-10 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0199965536 |
In Extra-Legal Power and Legitimacy: Perspectives on Prerogative, Clement Fatovic and Benjamin A. Kleinerman examine the costs and benefits associated with how governments have yielded extra-legal powers in times of emergency.
Settled Versus Right
Title | Settled Versus Right PDF eBook |
Author | Randy J. Kozel |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 191 |
Release | 2017-06-06 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 110712753X |
This book analyzes the theoretical nuances and practical implications of how judges use precedent.
The Rights Paradox
Title | The Rights Paradox PDF eBook |
Author | Michael A. Zilis |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Total Pages | 195 |
Release | 2021-04-15 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1108832091 |
What happens to the legitimacy of the Supreme Court when it protects 'equal justice under law'?
Tocqueville's Nightmare
Title | Tocqueville's Nightmare PDF eBook |
Author | Daniel R. Ernst |
Publisher | Oxford University Press, USA |
Total Pages | 241 |
Release | 2014 |
Genre | History |
ISBN | 0199920869 |
De Tocqueville once wrote that 'insufferable despotism' would prevail if America ever acquired a national administrative state. Between 1900 and 1940, radicals created vast bureaucracies that continue to trample on individual freedom. Ernst shows, to the contrary, that the nation's best corporate lawyers were among the creators of 'commission government'; that supporters were more interested in purging government of corruption than creating a socialist utopia; and that the principles of individual rights, limited government, and due process were designed into the administrative state.